Obvious, catholic jewish dating apologise, but
Posted in Dating
This was the norm for me: I was raised by two secular Jewish parents in a New Jersey suburb with a prominent Jewish population. I attended Hebrew school, had a bat mitzvah, lit Shabbat candles, went on Birthright. Jewish culture, thought, and ritual was and still is important to me. But once I got to college, I knew observing Judaism - and how I did so - was up to me. Another accepted norm for me was the Nice Jewish Boy, two of whom I dated in high school. They knew the rules of kashrut but loved trayf. I accepted that some answers were out of reach at that time, but I took what I could.
As long as you are open with your partner and potential future kids, compromise can very much be reached. My point with all of this rambling is that inter-faith relationships involving children are totally possible. You just need to figure out with your boyfriend whether or nor it will work for the two of you, and if so, what that will look like, realistically. Good luck! ArtsyGirl March 17,am.
"Relations between the Jewish people and the Catholic Church have never been as good" - ENN 2019-0
My bother- in law is Episcopalian and his wife is Jewish. They have been big on mixing their religious beliefs for both their wedding and raising their son. They got married in a hotel neutral ground with both a priest and a rabbi leading the service. Their son had a brit milah and a baptism. There will be a lot of compromise no matter who you marry so if you are willing to meet him halfway and he you I am sure it can work out.
I am glad to read the comments containing success stories of interfaith families. Is he devout? Though of course he respects your faith, does he truly believe it is as valid and true as his own?
I think for these unions to work, both parties need to be of somewhat progressive or liberal orders of their faith. But you can be serious about your faith and practice without being rigidly dogmatic or close-minded to others. MissDre March 17,am. I knew a guy whose mother was Buddhist and his father was Muslim. They seemed to make it work, so I definitely any couple can if they are willing to compromise. Skyblossom March 17,am. It is an issue but a very workable issue and I think most of us know happy marriages between a Jew and a Christian.
Is it just this issue that he has trouble discussing or is it all major issues? Maracuya March 17,am. Wendy March 17,am. WatersEdge March 17,am. Like she is open to the idea of compromise in theory, but what she really wants is to flat-out raise the kids Jewish?
I think that the LW needs to really figure out what she wants from her boyfriend. Would you really forbid the Easter Bunny?
Catholic jewish dating
That means get educated on the religion at least on a basic level, and encourage your children to explore both religions and observe both holidays. One of my biggest pet peeves is when people use religion as a means of being closeminded or negative. Maybe you should work on finding the positives in Christianity, and helping your boyfriend find the positives in Judaism, to embrace religion instead of letting it become an obstacle.
Sarah March 17,pm. I just think that, if the bf WANTS Christmas, they are not going to find common ground and someone will have to give or they break up.
Agreeing with Sarah here. Compromising how you handle a situation is VERY different from compromising your belief systems. The two can and should go together. If she were married, yes, she should push forward and do her best to compromise, to keep her marriage intact.
Guy Friday March 17,pm. However, if I may suggest an approach to take, my fiancee and I have agreed that when we have children, we will raise our kids Catholic, because the specific faith of her children matters a great deal to her and not as much to me.
Again, I completely disagree. I do not believe that two equally active, orthodox practitioners of different religions can find enough common ground to sustain a marriage and child-raising-if the tenets of the religion require NON-compromise. A direct conversation, perhaps with a non-affiliated or multi-faith counselor present, or with the couple consulting a Catholic counselor and a Jewish counselor to moderate or suggest possible solutions, might help bring the issue to clarity.
LSS86 March 17,pm. Just tell your boyfriend that. WatersEdge March 17,pm. She also said that she has explored her faith more recently, so that may have something to do with why she got into the relationship v. Quakergirl March 17,pm. Re-reading this letter, now, I think you make a great point WatersEdge. Are we seriously suggesting that she forbid her Catholic future husband from celebrating his own religious holiday?
Raising your kids Jewish is fine, and it definitely seems like she wants that. But in reality, it seems like what might make her more comfortable is a Jewish husband. Inter-faithed March 18,pm. If our kids would be raised Jewish, there would be no Christmas tree in my house. Most years I imagine we would take the kids to visit his parents for Christmas and there would be the big family dinner, their family would all attend mass, and yes there would be a Christmas tree.
My kids and I would probably not go to mass, but we would participate in everything else. After all, its nice to visit with grandma and grandpa. Would I encourage their Catholic father to go to church? Would I prepare a nice family dinner? But would there be a christmas tree in the living room and lights on the front of the house? I would never stop him from observing the holiday or pretend I could keep the kids from seeing Christmas.
They would just know its a nice holiday, fun to celebrate, fun to see family, but not their holiday. Kate March 18,pm. No, you are correct, IMO. I do not understand this at all, maybe because I was raised in a Catholic family. Quakergirl March 19,pm. For example, would you let him listen to Christmas music in the house? When you go to your parents, you can celebrate there, but not at home. And again, no judgment whatsoever no matter where you land. One of my co-workers is Catholic and his wife is Jewish.
But does he also want to celebrate the cultural and religious traditions of his faith, as well? Is it important to him to have his children raised Catholic and to become confirmed members of that church? To attend church every Sunday? To send his kids to Catholic schools? Is it important for him to be married in a Catholic church? Are you okay with raising your kids in a multi-cultural, multi-religious household? The married thing can be handled much easier, though.
You can do a lot of different things with a wedding, so that is so much easier to compromise on. Perhaps it just means you are not meant for each other, and better to know now before you get too entangled. SherBear March 17,am.
It was fun as a child to learn about all of the different customs and celebrations. The key was the respect amongst all of the adults for different belief systems.
Top Right Menu
If your boyfriend can truely respect your religion then yes it can work, but if there is any type of resentment then your future kids will start feeling like they have to pick sides. I agree with Wendy that discussing being married by a rabbi is a good test for his willingness to put his belief system aside for you.
Mainer March 17,am.
Man, kids. Always complicating things. We see bi-lingual children as gifted, yet we have this huge issue with raising our children to practice two religions. The only thing it does is expose them to more of what the world has to offer so they are that much more culturally rich.
When they get older, if they are more into one religion over the other, then let them choose. Actually, that sounds like a pretty good deal. As they get older, I would hope any child of mine would have been exposed to a myriad of cultures and beliefs and found one that made them feel spiritually whole.
That goes for anything. While not everyone holds the same religious views, they have a right to hold them and a right to teach them to their kids. Why would a parent do anything else? They can be exposed to different thought processes and ways of life while still keeping family life grounded in one belief.
However, I want to share my beliefs but not force my child to follow them - I want them to discover what is important to them and to develop their own spirituality. I feel that you can share your core beliefs with a child apart from your religious beliefs and that is how I would choose to raise my child.
I am not negating in any way the right of a parent to raise their own child to follow their beliefs but I also have the right to respectfully disagree with it and I would certainly not tell another parent how to raise their child. I also feel that some children can not properly grasp the importance of spirituality in their lives at a young age but I would certainly not prevent them from being introduced to it. Religions are not just holiday traditions, each religion makes claims about the world and they often conflict with one another.
Is there original sin or not? Is Jesus your savior or not? Are there saints or not?
"I'm Jewish, He's Catholic. Can We Make It Work?"
Amy March 17,am. Another thing that would be worthwhile to consider is the level of acceptance your families will show your relationship. And then - whether any lack of acceptance will cause relationship problems between the two of you. Families and friends can have such an influence on a relationship - for the good or the bad. Diann March 17,pm. Good point. He may not care but is he strong enough to stand up to familial pressure?
Will he want to? Will you? On the other hand, a big part of modern Judaism is about believing that the world is still waiting for the Messiah something directly in conflict with Christian beliefs. That said, in my experience this question is much more complicated for Jews.
Catholics and Lutherans and a few other denominations, as well as individuals in any denomination have a healthy respect for Jews and do not believe they need conversion, because of the previous covenant.
Many Christian beliefs and traditions are based on the Jewish beliefs and traditions from which Christianity sprung, and anyone who grew up going to Catholic etc Sunday School probably knows all about that.
Right, but a person who only speaks Spanish is likely only to be sensitive to Spanish culture, and vise versa for English. But if a person speaks both, it is likely that they understand and respect each of those cultures. In that sense, I guess I was speaking more along the lines of culturally religious. But on the other hand, practicing religion in a much lighter sense entails an understanding of the history and respect for the practices, as well as belonging to a community of fellow followers.
As long as you are not emphasizing that one is better than the other, or one way of life is better than another, I think they can practice both. They are going in opposite directions and neither of them is willing to make room to let the other pass. Spoiler alert: the whole world keeps going. Except for those two Zax. Who stand in the same place presumably for the rest of their lives while a bustling city is built around them.
The last page of the story is wild with bright colors and a new skyline and the Zax are frowning under a highway bypass because they still refuse to change direction. It stars another Dad-in-Distress named David. David was a very kind man. David was a very patient man. David liked fresh tomatoes and classical music and my mom. This was unacceptable to me. My mom had been widowed for about five years when she met David through a friend of a friend of a rabbi of a friend.
Yes, David was Jewish. He also honked instead of laughing whenever he thought something was funny, so I decided to call him The Honker. When Mom and The Honker got married in our living room, I wore a dark dress and pouted in all the pictures. The Honker was ridiculously chipper in the morning.
I was in eleventh grade at the time, and each day when I came downstairs, he wanted to chat about colleges, especially Bucknell. The Honker loved Bucknell. The Renos know that they will have to reckon further with their theological differences, if not in this life then in the next. A more orthodox believer would say that while there may be two ways of seeing God, ultimately only one way can be correct.
The Renos, for example, know that they will have to reckon further with their theological differences, if not in this life then in the next. It's interesting reading this article in light of some of the research I have been doing recently on some of the earlier Church councils. Isidore of Seville, both mandated that the children of such mixed marriages be baptized, and severely frowned on mixed marriages generally.
Catholic jewish dating - If you are a middle-aged woman looking to have a good time dating man half your age, this advertisement is for you. Men looking for a woman - Women looking for a man. Register and search over 40 million singles: chat. Aug 05, Dear Gefilte, I've tried everything else I can think of. Maybe you can help. My year old college-graduate daughter has been dating a Catholic boy, also a college graduate since they met in high school. He's a nice boy, and on a personal level, I like him very much, which I've told both him and [ ]. Aug 30, Judaism, as I've come to know it, is about questioning. It's about speaking up when you don't understand, challenging traditions, and, most of all, asking why. This was the norm for me: I was raised by two secular Jewish parents in a New Jersey suburb with a prominent Jewish population. I attended Hebrew school, had [ ]Author: Elana Spivack.
Worth remembering that separation and segregation between faith traditions was considered a desirable thing for many centuries, often on all sides. Liberal tolerance of such things is a relatively recent thing, less than years old in most cases.
This Polish American cradle Catholic from OH married a nice Jewish boy from NY 37 years ago this month and have been very happy ever since, in spite of initial resistance from my parents and reactions from other Catholics and Jews. His family loved me, and my parents eventually came around. As the article points out, it depends on the couple and their flavors of faith. My husband was raised in a very secular household in which his parents rarely went to a temple or celebrated the holidays.
I was educated in RC and also public schools with lots of Catholics. In college I met lots of Jews, dated Jewish men, and liked them as a group a lot. I met my soulmate when we were Army officers stationed in Germany. We later had two daughters we raised in the church.
Although a practicing Catholic, I decided they should also know about Judaism at least culturally, plus I enjoy cooking, so I hosted family events like seders and Rosh Hashanah dinners. Occasionally they went to temple with their Jewish grandparents who celebrated first communions and confirmations with us.
My husband never had any interest in becoming an observant Jew or converting to Catholicism or any other form of Christianity. He supported the religious instruction of our daughters and attended watershed events at our parish like his parents.
The older daughter, who seriously considered conversion to Judaism and went on a Birthright trip to Israel, came back to the church later when she began to practice law. My girl saw what the church did for the poor and dispossessed, and decided that she wanted a RC education for any future children. She and her husband, a Protestant who attended RC schools, are raising their sons in the church. The younger girl, who graduated from an RC high school and a UMC college with lots of RC students, is attending religious instructions at a reform temple and definitely thinks she will convert to Judaism.
Go figure! We are all OK with each other, because we love each other, differences and all In the end, that's the most important thing that we love God and each other. This article had great meaning for me personally, as well as spiritually.
In December, I will celebrate 50 years of marriage to my Methodist Christian wife. As a young man, my Catholic pastor passionately tried to dissuade me from proceeding with Cana instruction.
I suspect most Catholics, and certainly priests consider me excommunicated because of my views in senior years. The fact is I respect my wife's upbringing, including family and church life. To complicate matters, my career as a musician, teacher, performer allowed me to direct choirs in seven Protestant, one Jewish and eight Catholic places of worship. I respect and love all of these people. I don't look at them with the suspicion I was taught in my parochial schools from K through University grad.
My placement in a family tradition, race, ethnicity, corner of the world is ordered by God, just as it was for my Protestant wife. Although I respect my Catholic faith, I am not convinced the people I've encountered in different faith backgrounds have any less of a chance for salvation.
I respect your view if you disagree, but it works for our 50 years of marriage. He holds a Ph. Your source for jobs, books, retreats, and much more.
Faith Features September 4, issue. Mark Oppenheimer August 24, When a Jew and a Catholic marry. Love on the Margins: What Catholic interfaith couples share with the divorced and remarried. When Muslims and Christians Marry. Rita George Tvrtkovic. Show Comments 3. Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more. Most popular.
Living with pre-grief amid a pandemic. Pope Francis joins Muslim leaders in calling for world day of prayer to end the coronavirus. The Unity Project. Missionary Cenacle Volunteers at Trinita. Loretto Volunteer Program.
This Polish American cradle Catholic from OH married a nice Jewish boy from NY 37 years ago this month and have been very happy ever since, in . Mar 17, "I'm Jewish, He's Catholic. Can We Make It Work?" you need to be very clear about that with your boyfriend. Since you're dating a Catholic though, I'm assuming you are willing to make at least some compromises. And if that's the case, you need to decide what those compromises are. Instead of just demanding Jewish or.
See all Classifieds. The latest from america. Sean Salai, S. May 05, On Giving Tuesday, you can practice philanthropy with only a few dollars and some imagination. The coronavirus pandemic should not make us feel helpless, writes Thomas J.
I am final, I am sorry, but, in my opinion, this theme is not so actual.01.04.2020|Reply
It is very a pity to me, I can help nothing to you. I think, you will find the correct decision. Do not despair.02.04.2020|Reply
In my opinion you are not right. Write to me in PM.02.04.2020|Reply